I'm going to try "Rise." I liked Josh Radnor in Mercy Street. I loved Fame back in the day, although it was set in New York City at a special high school for the performing arts. so I don't see the parallels.

Sheriff Jody Mills, and her all-female hunter team, including her wards Alex and Claire, cop Donna Hanscum, and two new characters, psychic Patience and dreamwalker Kaia -- go off to save Sam and Dean who got stuck in an alternate reality.

The summary sounds like crack!fic--in a good way.