I totally agree with your opinion of Mark watches. Not super enlightening, but a lot of fun to relive seeing Buffy for the first time, and he's super delightful when he gets excited about stuff. Plus I think it's hard to be super analytical your first time through, without the big picture in mind. I can't wait to read his reaction to Dawn's entrance, Glory, Spike's redemption arc, The Body, OMWF ... the whole thing just makes me so excited, like I was my first time through.

And if you're ever looking for a chapter-by-chapter breakdown of why the Twilight Saga sucks, he's your go-to guy. If you can keep from getting FURIOUS!!! they are entertaining in an absurd I-can't-believe-this-got-published-and-people-don't-vomit-all-over-the-page-while-reading-it kind of way.