I can see the Emma/Hook chemistry, but I'm dead against that pairing. It's one thing for Emma to fall for the thief-with-a-heart-of-gold Bae/Neal brand bad-boy, another thing entirely for her to fall for the slimy-blow-with-the-wind Hook brand bad boy. The way she is written, she'd have to lose a lot of her "nobility" to go there, and I just don't see her doing it, not in an all-out way, and not in a Belle/Rumple "you can change!" way (which would suck all the sexy out of Hook if it happened).

I agree. Milla made sense, Emma doesn't. Also it's too...oh my Mom did it, and now Emma's doing the same thing? No.

Emma giving up Henry in a manner that is oddly similar to Snow makes sense.
Emma "hooking" up with Captain Hook...doesn't. Although they appear to playing Hook as a sort of Jack Sparrow type of character, with Emma as a shout-out to the Swan character in Pirates of the Caribbean...

But I do agree with you. We're talking about a character with serious trust issues, the last thing she'd do is hook up with a Pirate.

Besides, I'm a Neal(Bae)/Emma shipper. I like Bae better than Hook, find him to be more layered and far more interesting. Hook hasn't been developed enough. I wish they'd made Michael Raymond James a regular...but it did take the guy playing Hook (Colin O'Donogue) at least ten episodes before that happened.

They better not kill Bae, I'll be highly annoyed. He's my new favorite male character.

Hook, Regina and Rumple have a long way to go before they come close to being redeemed. Plus, I still haven't quite forgiven Hook for taking Aurora's heart and shooting Belle. He's not a nice guy. And I think Bae is hotter, personally.