Feb. 4th, 2004

shadowkat: (Dru in shadow)
Or so said Nietzche at some point in his writings. The quote is from Beyond Good and Evil and is uttered by a character in the recent Charlie Kaufman film Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind.

Last night, I ventured out into the cold pouring rain to see a pre-showing of this film, courtesy of my friend cjlasky who'd gotten free tickets.
This in of itself is an adventure, partly because the rain in NY has a funny habit of falling sideways, almost as if the heaven's know that they have to get around umbrellas and canopies and rooves to get things wet. The other reason is the wind, which has a funny way of getting underneath your umbrella and turning it inside out. Using an umbrella in NYC is well tricky. I've broken ten umbrellas since I moved here 8 years ago. Walk more than five blocks, with wind? Count on being soaked.
Add to this that the theater was neatly tucked away in the West Village, which is hard enough to navigate your way through in broad daylight let alone at night in a down-pour. Needless to say? I almost got lost, dodging water puddles, traffic, and well slanting rain. Finally I lucked out, backtracking the way I'd come and saw the theater across the street.

Was supposed to meet cjlasky there at 5:50. I got there at 5:45, just five minutes early. Introduced myself to the people in charge and sat myself down in the nice, dry, warm lobby to wait. The theater itself was tiny, about six rows, comfortable blue velvet, a group of black leather arm-chairs in the back row that reminded me of dentist chairs. And a fairly large rectangular screen. Well soon it was 6pm. No cjl. I went out front to talk to the people in charge. They were starting the movie at 10 of 6 apparently, whether the rep showed or not. She was late too. Train problems. 6:10, no cjl. I was advised to go watch the movie, they'd send him in when he arrived. Fearing I'd somehow lost cjl, I shrugged my shoulders, gave his name, was given admittance and picked the best viewing seat I could find. Which was not an aisle. (The aisle seats were crappy.)

About thirty minutes into the movie, cjl appeared and eventually found his way to a seat close to me.
Now here's the interesting part - it wasn't until thirty minutes into the movie that we got the title and the opening credits.

What follows is my atypical style of reviewing movies and tv shows - which is picking an element that fascinated me and flipping it back and forth between different shows and mediums in a stream of consciousness manner. Here - what interests me is the idea of memory. What happens when you wipe away or erase a portion of the memory? When Angel wiped away Connor from the memories of everyone but himself - what effect did that have on those individuals? Is such a thing even possible without unraveling everything along with it? Same question about the addition of a memory - such as Dawn on BTVS, what did the addition of Dawn do to the memories of the people she was added to? When you add memory to a computer disk - it can corrupt or overload the disk, similarly when you remove something - if it's intergral to the program, that too disrupts the disk or corrupts it. So what does it do to the human mind?

Alfred Bester wondered about this in Demolished Man, where it was hypothesized that if you wipe clean a murder's memories you remove the inclination to murder. He did not, however pursue what happened once this was done. Bester was more concerned with the ethical quandry of doing it to begin with. Here, in Eternal Sunshine - Kauffman seems to wonder what happens when you do attempt to remove one person from someone's memories, what effect that has on the unconscious mind. Angel the Series - may end up exploring the same question but from another angle.

Mild Spoilers for Eternal Sunshine of The Spotless Mind and up to ATS 5.11 )

PS: I got my amazon books today. Harry Potter and the Philip K. Dick. They are currently sitting on my shelves waiting patiently to be read. Have to make it through Disorderly Knights and then Wicked first. Disorderly Knights is taking me an absurdly long time to read, I know.
shadowkat: (Dru in shadow)
After reading the newest book meme, I thought I'd do a little research, provide more information if I could - because I remembered when the Modern Library's notorious list was first released.

When the Modern Library - one of the imprints of Random House - released its list of 100 best or most influential books of the 20th Century along with the list that online voters/readers chose (I was actually one of the voters - although they didn't pick my number one choice which was Ulyssess by James Joyce), there was quite a bit controversary and hoopla over it. Why? The lack of minority fiction represented. The lack of works by non-English writers. The relative lack of women writers. People felt that a whole segment of the population was under-represented. Who were these judges anyway? And why were the majority of writers represented white men?

So, Radcliff Publishing course released their list.
And even more fascinating, the New York Public Library released a list of books and authors which they put on display when the millenium approached.
The best list is the NYPL list which I'm saving for another entry, this one being far too long.

So here? I'm just reproducing the Modern Library List, The Modern Library Reader's Choice List and the Radcliff list along with the one's I read in each list, which is embarrassingly few.

The Modern Libary Book Meme )

And now the Reader's Choice list for The Modern Library. This list was obtained from online and mailed in ballots to readers around the world. Mostly online. You could only vote once. In bold are the books I've read. And no I don't agree with the choices. Some of them ahem making you wonder about people.

The Modern Library List voted on by regular readers online or the cult list )

Here's the Radcliff publishing course's response, which I've read more of and sort of prefer to the above two lists. Is it more balanced than the Modern Library List? You be the judge.

Radcliff Publishing List of 100 Best Most Influential 20th Century Works )
Page generated Sep. 5th, 2025 01:50 am
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios