Thank you for answering my poll - currently it's tied between those who are ambivalent and those who have never read the comics or plan to. I have no idea why people feel that way. But it is fun to speculate. My guess is the characters as they are depicted in the comics, specifically the female lead (buffy) and the story the writers have chosen to tell no longer resonates with or speak to most people on an emotional level. That's a personal thing, totally pov and perspective - don't try arguing with people on that one. Won't work. Because you don't know why it doesn't resonate. It's more than likely what resonates for you is the very thing that is turning your friend off. This happens a lot with cultural stuff. For example - Bones. My friend from college and her hubby love Bones. I'd personally rather watch paint dry, be less annoying. Can't stand it. What worked for her, does not work for me. Meanwhile I adore the show House and she hates it. We can speculate all we want on why, but the truth of the matter is - it is what it is. Same deal with X-Files and Buffy, she wouldn't watch Buffy the Vampire Slayer if you paid her, and I was not a fan of the X-Files, although I did enjoy some of the stand-alone episodes, but mostly I found it too scary, too gross, and the whole alien conspiracy bit annoyed me. Alien conspiracy or aliens' invading or the US abusing aliens stories don't work for me - it's a sci-fi trope that I grew bored of ages ago. I know I'm in the minority on that - everybody online adores the X-files.
Speaking for myself in regards to the comics? ( Read more... )
As for writing and stories...read a few comments and an excellent post by
flake_sake
about what works in a story and what doesn't, which got me to thinking about what works for me, and wondering well...what works for everyone else? I'm guessing it's different for all of us, because hello, we think differently. I remember way back in 2003 posting an essay on the APTO board about the episode Storyteller (Buffy S7) which everyone and their mother adored to pieces.
I hated it. It was entitled, why I hated Storyteller - and was really an examination of differences in taste and why we don't always like things in the same or for the same reasons or even, in most cases like the same things at all.
( very long ramble...and not edited. )
Speaking for myself in regards to the comics? ( Read more... )
As for writing and stories...read a few comments and an excellent post by
![[livejournal.com profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/external/lj-userinfo.gif)
about what works in a story and what doesn't, which got me to thinking about what works for me, and wondering well...what works for everyone else? I'm guessing it's different for all of us, because hello, we think differently. I remember way back in 2003 posting an essay on the APTO board about the episode Storyteller (Buffy S7) which everyone and their mother adored to pieces.
I hated it. It was entitled, why I hated Storyteller - and was really an examination of differences in taste and why we don't always like things in the same or for the same reasons or even, in most cases like the same things at all.
( very long ramble...and not edited. )