I think what draws me to a character is either a flaw I identify with or resonates on some level or a surprise, they surprise me, do something unexpected, yet makes total sense. I don't like black and white characters...or simple ones. It's hard to pigeon hole though.
When I think of my favorite genre characters, it's usually because they hit some weird unexplainable chord inside. It's deeply personal and woe to anyone who begrudges me my right to adore them unassailed. (ie. Like a momma tiger - I will bear my fangs and rip you to shreds, often going after your favorites to protect my own. Although, I think I've matured over the past ten years...and am less likely to do it now. I actually shrugged off an anti-(one of fav characters) post on my flist this past week. And have multiple times in the past. Because while it is lovely when people agree with us, most of the time they don't. That's when it is tough. Not letting well-meaning but annoyingly opinionated friends harsh on your squee. )
Favorite Characters...Male, Female and what have you...
*
( Spike )*
( Angel )*
( John Crichton )*
( Scott Summers (Cyclops)/Lee Adama (Apollo) )*
( Aeryn Sun )*
( Tyrion/Jamie Lannister/Starbuck and Nolan and Veronica Mars )*
( Doctor Who )*
( Doctor River Song )*
( Frodo )*
( Diane and Alicia Florek )What I need in a good character is complexity, but also something that rings true, feels real, hits me inside. Makes me want more. To see what happens next. Rialyn(sp??) in
Justified, the lead character played by Timothy Olyphant...is not what you'd expect, he's not the black and white marshal of the Western landscape. And his best bud and outlaw who makes his life hell at every turn, continues to mesmerize. Or in
The Wire, the chaotic good cheer of the charming Det. Jimmy McNulty, played beautifully by Dominic West in an unrecognizable Baltimore accent. He mesmerizes...with his desire to buck the system, but more often than not devastated by the results, stating in hollow pain..what the fuck did I do..far too late for it to matter. While there are certainly more outlandish and memorable characters...such as Butters or Omar, McNulty haunts me the most...because he is in effect a cautionary tale much like Frodo Baggins in Lord of the Rings...no Harry Potter or even a Bunny Colvin...McNulty is interesting because he fails not because he wins.
It is often those that fail...and fall that are the most interesting to me, for they are the most real and human. Not the anti-heroes who kick people and then die bloody, too easy I think. Or the irreedeemable anti-heroes who start out as jerks and well only give a hint at being redeemed, only to be jerks again. No...it's the good blokes, the people who are good at heart, who try, and try hard and fall...that resonate the most and seem the most real. Then get up and try again. The Lee Adamas, Scott Summers, Spike, Angel, Aeryn Sun, John Crichton, even Buffy Summers...who look at the man or woman in the mirror, stare them in the eye..and try much like Jimmy McNulty and Frodo...or even poor old Veronica Mars, to somehow make sense of it all.