I suppose I should do separate reviews, but easier to just do them all at once. This is basically, the good (House), the okay (SPN), the bad (Terra Nova), and the just plain ugly (American Horror Story) - although to be fair are any horror stories supposed to be pretty?
1. House - I think we are on S6 or S7, can't remember which, not sure if it will be the finale season or not. Will state that the premier was surprisingly good. Reminded me of the episode in which House was in the psychiatric ward for several months. ( spoilers )
2. Terra Nova - hmmm, this appears to be as poorly written as BBC's Outcasts and has more in common with Outcasts than with either Jurrassic Park or Earth 2, which is not a good sign. Quite dumb in places. The second episode is worse than the pilot. I'm beginning to understand why David Fury jumped ship - it's really not his cup of tea, too...Swiss Family Robinson, not enough Jurassic Park. The writing makes Star Gate look like Shakespeare in comparison. Very clunky and silly. But, I remain curious about a few things - so may stick with it a bit longer. I know it is basically dead in the water. The series is too expensive to survive the low ratings it has, but Fox invested so much into it - that it will run all 12 episodes, which I guess is better than what they did with Lone Star (although Lone Star was a better written television series.)
3. SPN or Supernatural - eh, not thrilling me.( vague spoilers )
4. American Horror Story - sorry to say but Supernatural and Secret Circle were scarier this week than American Horror Story. The reason? I wasn't given any reason to care about the people in American Horror Story. Note to Ryan Murphy and Brad Falchuck - it's a good idea to build up the audience's sympathy for the main characters before you start with all the scares and hijnks. Even Kubrick seemed to understand that concept, at least to a degree, with The Shining. American Horror Story borrows heavily from classic haunted house horror films. There's the Geoffrey Rush remake of House on Haunted Hill with all the bizarre experiments in the basement and jaws with baby heads, the gothic windows of Amityville Horror and the fire references, the twins from The Shining, and the beautiful woman seducing the husband who in reality is an old and possibly dead crone - also from The Shining. It's almost as if they took these films threw them in a meat grinder and added a few bits from Eyes Wide Shut.
I didn't find the episode all that shocking. I don't know what that says about me? Or that scary. Just sort of dull and a bit boring.
Nor did I really care about any of the characters. The best - are Vivian (Connie Britton), the wife who lost her child, and Connie (Jessica Lange) , the nosy neighbor, but that has more to do with the actresses than the script. Dylan McDermot isn't having enough fun with the role - and I already miss the guys from Nip/Tuck - Dylan Walsh would been better in this role...McDermot lacks warmth. (I'm admittedly not a fan of the actor - didn't like him in The Practice either.)
The plot isn't that complicated.
( detailed spoilers for the first episode )
1. House - I think we are on S6 or S7, can't remember which, not sure if it will be the finale season or not. Will state that the premier was surprisingly good. Reminded me of the episode in which House was in the psychiatric ward for several months. ( spoilers )
2. Terra Nova - hmmm, this appears to be as poorly written as BBC's Outcasts and has more in common with Outcasts than with either Jurrassic Park or Earth 2, which is not a good sign. Quite dumb in places. The second episode is worse than the pilot. I'm beginning to understand why David Fury jumped ship - it's really not his cup of tea, too...Swiss Family Robinson, not enough Jurassic Park. The writing makes Star Gate look like Shakespeare in comparison. Very clunky and silly. But, I remain curious about a few things - so may stick with it a bit longer. I know it is basically dead in the water. The series is too expensive to survive the low ratings it has, but Fox invested so much into it - that it will run all 12 episodes, which I guess is better than what they did with Lone Star (although Lone Star was a better written television series.)
3. SPN or Supernatural - eh, not thrilling me.( vague spoilers )
4. American Horror Story - sorry to say but Supernatural and Secret Circle were scarier this week than American Horror Story. The reason? I wasn't given any reason to care about the people in American Horror Story. Note to Ryan Murphy and Brad Falchuck - it's a good idea to build up the audience's sympathy for the main characters before you start with all the scares and hijnks. Even Kubrick seemed to understand that concept, at least to a degree, with The Shining. American Horror Story borrows heavily from classic haunted house horror films. There's the Geoffrey Rush remake of House on Haunted Hill with all the bizarre experiments in the basement and jaws with baby heads, the gothic windows of Amityville Horror and the fire references, the twins from The Shining, and the beautiful woman seducing the husband who in reality is an old and possibly dead crone - also from The Shining. It's almost as if they took these films threw them in a meat grinder and added a few bits from Eyes Wide Shut.
I didn't find the episode all that shocking. I don't know what that says about me? Or that scary. Just sort of dull and a bit boring.
Nor did I really care about any of the characters. The best - are Vivian (Connie Britton), the wife who lost her child, and Connie (Jessica Lange) , the nosy neighbor, but that has more to do with the actresses than the script. Dylan McDermot isn't having enough fun with the role - and I already miss the guys from Nip/Tuck - Dylan Walsh would been better in this role...McDermot lacks warmth. (I'm admittedly not a fan of the actor - didn't like him in The Practice either.)
The plot isn't that complicated.
( detailed spoilers for the first episode )